Speech of Aristophanes - YouTube

Aristophanes Views on Love In the Symposium, a most interesting view on love and soul mates are provided by one of the characters, Aristophanes. In the speech of Aristophanes, he ...

The Speech of Aristophanes - YouTube

R. G. Bury, The Symposium of Plato, Speech of Aristophanes

189a-193d Speech of Aristophanes (the Dramatist): Eros is a healer.

The speech of Aristophanes in Plato's Symposium is notable in that its central metaphor survives to the present day. Though people are not generally aware of its attribution, in its genericized form it is part of contemporary discourse. Audiences require no explanation when hearing the title character in the film Jerry Maguire utter “You complete me” to the one he loves. Nor does she, but rather is overcome by the sentiment. It is a poetic formulation, the idea that human loneliness and the need for companionship are borne of estrangement from our original selves and that this eternal dissatisfaction was meted out by a higher power when we overreached our bounds. We had it, we blew it, we lost it. A later formulation of the same idea, the Old Testament tale of Adam and Eve, has achieved even wider cultural currency. In the conceptions of both Genesis and Plato's Aristophanes, companions share a connection rooted in the physical. Where Adam suffers the loss of a rib as raw material for the construction of his Eve, in Aristophanes the bonds between pairs of humans exist from the outset, as they share eight-limbed bodies, and the pain of their later separation is suggested by the bodily aspects of their forcible disjunction (26, 190E-191A). It is as though Aristophanes is responding to Eryximachus in kind, medical explanation for medical explanation.

Speech of Aristophanes - Plato The Symposium - TeacherTube

Recall too, the Fourth Speech of Aristophanes in Plato's .There we read that humans were once ball-like beings rolling through thecosmos. Such a prenatal experience can be recollected as a result of applyingthe -principle, the technique of thinking of nothing. In thewords of my Tao Meditation guide, Fangfu: In ordinary life it is the worldsurrounding us that determines our consciousness. In Tao Meditation itis the (gradually expanding) consciousness that determines (enhances) ourperception of the world.

Phdr. 230e–234c. Think of the so-called myth of Protagoras, or of the speech of Aristophanes in Smp.
Speech of Aristophanes: French animated adaptation of Plato’s Symposium (189d-191d) with English subtitles :

Speech of Aristophanes (Plato, The Symposium 189d-191d)

Although Plato does highlight the inability of poetry to present aphilosophically reasoned argument, nevertheless I think that there are many aspects of Aristophanes’ speech which Plato does wish to present as valid ideas. It is not so much the conclusions that Aristophanes draws in his speech that are contradictory to Plato’s own ideas, but rather it is the way in which Aristophanes justifies his conclusions that strike Plato as contrary to philosophical reasoning. It is significant that Plato, when speaking of the types of poetry to be banned from his ideal city in the , gives Socrates these words:

Speech of Aristophanes: French animated adaptation of Plato’s Symposium (189d-191d) with English subtitles :

Speech of Aristophanes on Vimeo

The comedian, Aristophanes, is humorous and fanciful. ... To many people, ruling out the speech of Aristophanes should be obvious. ... This leaves only the speeches of Agathon and Socrates himself. ... This was the major flaw in the speeches of Phaedrus, Pausanias, Aristophanes and Eryximachus. ... In short, Socrates describes perfectly the nature of love. ...

Speech of Aristophanes: French animated adaptation of Plato’s Symposium (189d-191d) with English subtitles :

189c-193e (Speech of Aristophanes)

Much of the success of Plato as a philosopher can be attributed to hisabilityto present philosophical reasoning and moral education in the guise of entertaining dialogues and scenarios. No other philosopher matches Plato in the ability to provide works that are as comic as they are philosophical. Yet even more significant when discussing Plato is that the philosophical rigor of his works is not compromised by the entertaining format in which they are written. His works are important to the reader in our time primarily as philosophical texts, and the validity of Plato’s reasoning must be examined just as in any other work of philosophy or literature. In a work such as the , in which the comedic aspect of the dialogue is emphasized so greatly, it becomes difficult to discuss the text in terms of its philosophical value. Indeed, there are many characteristics of the that leave the modern reader with a number of doubts and unresolved ambiguities. Not least of these difficult passages to interpret is the speech of Aristophanes, which occupies a central place in the work.