RCMP Sikh Turban Controversy? | Essay Service

Dhillon fought the RCMP turban ban, eventually taking his case to Norman Inkster, the force’s commissioner of the day. Inkster agreed with Dhillon, in the process igniting a fierce national debate. At issue was whether a cherished national symbol, the Mounties’ Stetson, should be set aside for the sake of an individual recruit’s religion. In 1990 the Mulroney government reversed the old policy, allowing turbans.

Niqab debate recalls RCMP turban furor of the '90s - MSN

Niqab debate recalls RCMP turban furor of the '90s

Niqab debate recalls RCMP turban furor of the '90s

The good reason for objecting to RCMPturbans is that symbols of religion and the state should remain separate in Canada. People who adopt this position say they wouldn't want to see Mounties wearing a Christian cross, a Jewish yarmulka or a Sikh turban because these symbols suggest the state is not secular.

the RCMP turban debate and kirpan issue

This bio-documentary is a very timely effort and a contribution to Sikh history. For example, Hew Mcleod's "Textual Sources on Guru Nanak" is a classic, as well as his translation of Bhai Chaupa Singh's Rehatnama. Many of the questions he has raised in history need to be faced; we can't brush them aside as many would like to do. Of course, when he dismisses our tradition and lore - that riles us and rightly so. His wonderful expertise was most helpful in the RCMP turban case not so long ago. There are many more issues that people have raised but their detailed treatment is not pertinent here. The fact that there are differing opinions on his work indicates that he has stirred minds and that is important. To foster discussion and debate is one of the most important things that a scholar can and should do. Despite the Sikh community's important and substantial differences with him, Hew McLeod has been an articulate and important voice in Sikh history.


His wonderful expertise was most helpful in the RCMP turban case not so long ago

Sikhs to wear the turban while on active duty in the RCMP.

~ [OP-ED] July 13, 2012 by Linda Goyette, ..

Sikhs and the turban go together